Preferences

all visas will go to tech, and no visas will go to Nurses, professors, teachers, artists etc

So nurses, professors, teachers and artists will be in higher demand and they'll have to pay them a better salary to fill positions? which may attract people who currently avoid those career cause they lead to poverty? Yup I'm sold.

And as others said, add a cost factor to train an citizen for every H-1B issued. Actually, slap a 350% tax on all the salaries paid to H-1Bs except for the first 15 people (or, I don't know, 3% of the overall staff, whichever is higher) and make sure it's hard to game with shell companies, body shops and subsidiaries.

Precisely 0% chance it'll happen in the current administration, and it's anyone guess if there will be administrations after this one, but a few hours of additional thinking around this solution (this is the first 3 minutes roughly) could make it work way better. Remove limits, make it really expensive, give some rights to the people who come on it, use the money to address real shortages, and watch companies stop abusing it.

P.S. European here, with 0 interest in coming to work in the US.

I had no idea there was a huge shortage of professors, teachers, and artists.
there is always a demand for a talent in the US
Of course, and perhaps if you're having trouble with supply in famously poorly paid fields then paying better might help.
If they’re not willing to pay up, then there isn’t really a shortage.
same could be said of famines like the one in China or Soviet Union or ones in Africa: they simply needed to pay up for food, if they were really that hungry

your logic erases nuance of the US labor market and infinity of specializations and niches, on top or large regional differences in labor market.

let's just say that nurses will never be paid on par with software engineers just because it is different specialty, and it is stupid to force nurses to compete with IT for visas

If we think those things have positive externalities (such that we want them to happen even if they wouldn't win an auction) we should subsidize them.
Nurses generally can't get an H-1B, and professors are exempt. Your argument makes no sense.
I don't anticipate this will even get a committee hearing, let alone get passed into law.
I think it depends on whether Trump/Miller are behind it. If they are, then every Republican politician will fall in line without a peep.
approximately 500,000 foreign-educated nurses in the U.S. utilize the H-1B visa (per google AI overview)
I did not even know you can practice nursing in US without US-based degree.
Well canadian medical degrees are recognized fully, even canadian medical residencies are recognized fully in the US

Probably something similar to nursing programs

Google AI is wrong.

This item has no comments currently.

Keyboard Shortcuts

Story Lists

j
Next story
k
Previous story
Shift+j
Last story
Shift+k
First story
o Enter
Go to story URL
c
Go to comments
u
Go to author

Navigation

Shift+t
Go to top stories
Shift+n
Go to new stories
Shift+b
Go to best stories
Shift+a
Go to Ask HN
Shift+s
Go to Show HN

Miscellaneous

?
Show this modal