Comment by dalek_cannes

dalek_cannes Jun 15, 2014 parent

This comment does not warrant downvotes, even though it makes a hard-to-agree-with argument. I myself disagree with this on many counts, but the poster does present a legitimate question. Over-pathologization and trivialization both take place. The disagreement here is about the degree and prevalence.

hnnewguy Jun 15, 2014

>This comment does not warrant downvotes

Thankfully the system exists whereby one person (you) doesn't get to decide that.

Over-pathologization might be an issue, but isn't really the topic of discussion. Trying to misdirect the argument from "there's widespread depression" to "it's probably something else" is exactly part of the problem.

The OP is putting forward the same, tired arguments that "feeling like this is normal, get over it". Clearly and admittedly he has no experience or qualifications, so how the hell does he know?

http://hyperboleandahalf.blogspot.ca/2011/10/adventures-in-d...

h1karu Jun 15, 2014

The topic of the thread is "We need to talk about depression" therefor I'm on-topic. Just because I disagree with the premise of the article does not mean such opinions are misdirection or off-topic.

Your assertion that credentials are needed in order to form an opinion about what is and is not normal human experience is in my opinion ridiculous, and it borders on the "appeal to authority" logical fallacy.

This item has no comments currently.

Preferences

Keyboard Shortcuts

Story Lists

Navigation

Miscellaneous