Hacker Neue

Preferences
kobalsky parent
MCP servers are basically a tool call registries, how could it be worse than a regular tool call?
behnamoh
an MCP server can run code outside of the domain of tools that it supports, tool call can't
TeMPOraL
Tools are literally function calls with extra steps. MCPs are interpreters of those function calls.

Same stuff, different name - only thing that's changed is that Anthropic got people to agree on RPC protocol.

It's not like it's a new idea, either. MCP isn't much different from SOAP or DCOM - but it works where the older approaches didn't, because LLMs are able to understand API definitions and natural-language documentation, and then map between those APIs (and user input) on the fly.

brazukadev
> MCPs are interpreters of those function calls.

No, tool calls are just one of many MCP parts. People thinking MCP = SOAP or DCOM or JSON-RPC or OpenAPI didn't stop 20 minutes to read and understand MCP.

Tool calls is 20% of MCP, at maximum. And a good amount of it is dynamically generating the tool list exposed to LLMs. But lots of people here think MCP === give the model 50 tools to choose from

simonw
"Tool calls is 20% of MCP, at maximum"

What else is there? I know about resources and prompts but I've seen almost no evidence of people actually using them, as far as I can tell tools are 90% of the usage of MCP, if not more.

brazukadev
It is funny most people discussing here does not understand MCP at all. Besides tools, MCP has resources, prompts, sampling, elicitation, roots and each one of them is useful when creating apps connected to LLMs. MCP is not only about MCP Servers, the host/client part is as important as the servers/tools. For example, nowadays most LLM clients are chatbots, but an MCP client could be a chess game or a project management app.

> I know about resources and prompts but I've seen almost no evidence of people actually using them

these are features that MCP clients should implement and unfortunately, most of them still don't. The same for elicitation and sampling. Prompts, for example, are mostly useful when you use sampling, then you can create an agent from an MCP server.

7 More Comments →

This item has no comments currently.