Hacker Neue

Preferences
unsupp0rted parent
Yes, it's bad. Because we're all dying of cancer, heart disease and auto-immune disease, not to mention traffic accidents and other random killers that AI could warn us about and fix.

I don't mind losing my programming job in exchange for being able to go to the pharmacy for my annual anti-cancer pill.

amarcheschi
Or the funding for ai might have gone into curing cancer, heart disease, better research for urban planning, whatever that isn't ai
mirblitzarmaven
Fair point on improvements outside of garbage generative AI.

But, what happens when you lose that programming job and are forced to take a job at a ~50-70% pay reduction? How are you paying for that anti-cancer drug with a job with no to little health insurance?

lurking_swe
you move out of the US to a country that doesn’t hate its own people lol. That’s one option. Or pray you have good insurance.
assword
The usual answer to this question is that LLMs are on the verge of making Fully Automated Luxury Gay Space Communism a reality.
jplusequalt
Which is completely detached from reality. Where are the social programs for this? Hell, we've spent the last 8 months hampering social systems, not bolstering them.
tecleandor
I'd love that, but I have the feeling that Altman is not in that same page.
aeve890
>Yes, it's bad. Because we're all dying of cancer, heart disease and auto-immune disease, not to mention traffic accidents and other random killers that AI could warn us about and fix.

Any disease cured/death avoided by AI yet?

unsupp0rted OP
Possibly psoriasis, as a canary test case https://www.abcellera.com
calmoo
Is this really a useful argument? There is clearly potential for AI to solve a lot of important issues. Anybody saying "and has this cured x y or z?" before a huge discovery was made after years of research isn't a good argument to stop research.
aeve890
It is in the face of naive, overoptimistic arguments that straight up ignore the negative impacts, that IMO vastly outweigh the positive ones. We will have the cure of cancer, but everyone loses their jobs. This happened before, with nuclear energy. The utopia of clean, too cheap to meter nuclear energy never came, though we have enough nukes to glass the planet ten times over.

Stop pretending that the people behind this technology is genuinely motivated by what's best for humanity.

monocasa
There's rumors that ML played a part in the creation of the covid mRNA vaccines.
akomtu
What's the benefit for the AI masters to keep you in good health? Corporate healthcare exists only because it's necessary to keep workers making money for the corporation, but remove that need and corpos will dump us on the streets.
captainclam
It's very easy to imagine a world where all these things are solved, but it is a worse world to live in overall.

I don't think it is "bad" to be sincerely worried that the current trajectory of AI progress represents this trade.

dsign
Even if AI could help, it won’t in the current system. The current system which is throwing trillions into AI research on the incentive to replace expensive labor, all while people don’t have basic health insurance.
jrboyens
I mean, that presumes that the answer to generating your anti-cancer pill, or the universal cure to heart disease has already been found, but humans can't see it because the data is disparate.

The likelihood of all that is incredibly slim. It's not 0% -- nothing ever really is -- but it is effectively so.

Especially with the economics of scientific research, the reproducibility crisis, and general anti-science meme spreading throughout the populace. The data, the information, isn't there. Even if it was, it'd be like Alzheimer's research: down the wrong road because of faked science.

There is no one coming to save humanity. There is only our hard work.

apwell23
cancer is just aging . we all have to die somehow when its time to go.

How exactly do you wish death comes to you?

AuryGlenz
Cool. Tell that to my 35 year old friend who died of cancer last year. Or, better yet, the baby of a family friend that was born with brain cancer. You might have had a hard time getting her to hear you with all the screaming in pain she constantly did until she finally mercifully died before her first birthday, though.
unsupp0rted OP
Cancer is just aging like dying from tetanus or rabies is just aging. On a long enough timeline everybody eventually steps on a rusty nail or gets scratched by a bat.

If you solve everything that kills you then you don't die from "just aging" anymore.

apwell23
news to me that tetanus and rabies predominantly is affliction of the old

https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/health-professional/cancer-...

> Children aged 0-14, and teenagers and young adults aged 15-24, each account for less than one per cent

> Adults aged 25-49 contribute around 5 in 100 (4%) of all cancer death

oh yea can cancer has nothing to do with age, its just all random like stepping on a nail.

unsupp0rted OP
If not for everything else that kills you first, then tetanus and rabies is an affliction of the old.

But of course it's not, because we have near-100% cures for both. Just like we should have for every other affliction, which would make being old no longer synonymous with being sick and frail and dying.

apwell23
- 19% were in those <20 years, including a single neonatal case

- 20% in those 65 and older.

for tetanus

Age would be irrelevant even if cured everything else

I don't see how thats affliction of old

catigula
You're afraid to die so we should reorder society to fail to prevent it because reasons.
jplusequalt
>I don't mind losing my programming job in exchange for being able to go to the pharmacy for my annual anti-cancer pill

Have you looked at how expensive prescription drug prices are without (sometimes WITH) insurance? If you are no longer employed, good luck paying for your magical pill.

This item has no comments currently.

Keyboard Shortcuts

Story Lists

j
Next story
k
Previous story
Shift+j
Last story
Shift+k
First story
o Enter
Go to story URL
c
Go to comments
u
Go to author

Navigation

Shift+t
Go to top stories
Shift+n
Go to new stories
Shift+b
Go to best stories
Shift+a
Go to Ask HN
Shift+s
Go to Show HN

Miscellaneous

?
Show this modal