Noumenon72 parent
When I got to "There are hells on earth and Dubai is one" I scrolled back, thinking I had missed where they described that. Either it was left out of this book excerpt or the author has a prior revulsion at people being employed for tourism that makes their examples seem self-evidently awful to them only.
There's people working in Dubai who make very little money, have crowded, cramped, hot living quarters, will be jailed if they try to start a union, and have to do dangerous construction work in one of the hottest places on earth. When they die, their employers don't care. If one of these people described Dubai as "hell on earth", would you tell them they were being hyperbolic?
> If you try to humanise the place you will lose your mind. If you ask yourself what the woman at the hair-braiding stand left behind to be here, and why, you will lose your mind. If you accept the kindness of the staff with whom you make a paltry effort to speak each morning as they clear your dirty breakfast plate, you will lose your mind, because your tip is the only kindness you can meaningfully offer in return. Trying to attend to your own towel by the pool might cause the man who stands for hours in the ferocious sun to do so for you to lose his job. Being served makes us cruel infants. It demeans us all.
I understand this passage and can relate, "self-evidently awful to them only" seems a bit of a stretch. There are places on Earth where "being employed for tourism" means job security, worker rights and social protections, where staff is treated with respect and are allowed dignity.
> I scrolled back, thinking I had missed where they described that
The explanation of that phrase is in... the very next three sentences.
Oh, that makes sense. If the excerpt had started with that paragraph, I would have been expecting the next sentences to explain it. By being halfway through and starting with "I learnt nothing and left nauseated", I thought its function was to sum up what she had seen over her whole trip. Thanks for explaining how to read it.