Preferences

sorcerer-mar parent
okay I give up! You've aced Poe's test! Is this sarcasm or no?

kapildev
What's a Poe test? Is it related to Edgar Allen Poe? Couldn't find anything with a quick Google search
I think this bit gives it up:

> And now, with Iran's nuclear ambitions supposedly neutralized in a single blow, we can all relax. The threat is gone. No strategic aftershocks, no long term consequences, no unintended escalation. Just peace, stability, and a region completely satisfied with the outcome.

Sounds like sarcasm to me.

Ajedi32
Yeah, other than that paragraph I think it's a perfectly reasonable sentiment.

The threat is obviously not "gone". Just substantially reduced. And we can't relax, we need to be vigilant to make sure they don't rebuild. But this certainly does seem to have been a relatively simple solution to the problem of Iranian nuclear armament.

Diplomacy is of course still a better long-term solution. But even diplomacy is a lot easier when you get to start the negotiations from a position of "No, you can't have nukes, period, regardless of whether you agree to any sort of deal or not."

sorcerer-mar OP
No, it's really not better to start negotiations from a position of "we may unilaterally withdraw from any agreements you sign and comply with, then bomb you regardless of whether you are pursuing nukes."

This has unambiguously increased the imperative for Iran (and every other country) to acquire its own nuclear deterrent.

This item has no comments currently.