Hacker Neue

Preferences
mentalgear parent
The whole AI scene is starting to feel a lot like the cryptocurrency bubble before it burst. Don’t get me wrong, there’s real value in the field, but the hype, the influencers, and the flashy “salon tricks” are starting to drown out meaningful ML research (like Apple's critical research that actually improves AI robustness). It’s frustrating to see solid work being sidelined or even mocked in favor of vibe-coding.

Meanwhile, I asked this morning Claude 4 to write a simple EXIF normalizer. After two rounds of prompting it to double-check its code, I still had to point out that it makes no sense to load the entire image for re-orientating if the EXIF orientation is fine in the first place.

Vibe vs reality, and anyone actually working in the space daily can attest how brittle these systems are.

rxtexit
I think part of the problem is that people have the wrong mental models currently.

I am a non-software engineer and I fully expect someday to be a professional "vibe coder". It will be within a domain though and not a generalist like a real software engineer.

I think "vibe coding" in this context will have a type of relationship to software engineering the way excel has a relationship to the professional mathematician.

The knocks on "vibe coding" by software engineers are like a mathematician shitting on Excel for not being able to do symbolic manipulation.

It is not wrong but missing the forest for the trees.

This item has no comments currently.