5 years is the shortest, 15 is the longest. Their assumption is that 5 years is the minimum time that it provides value.
I don't think there's any real logic to it, it's just a way to balance the tax budget.
For 1, presuming that all software engineering is "research or experimental" is faulty. The vast majority of software engineers are implementing known things, and the "experimental" status reflects its reliability. Most "experimental" software isn't really doing experiments to answer questions, it's just checking whether an approach works correctly. I don't think anyone could honestly call writing an Okta integration for a SaaS app "experimental". You know that it will work ahead of time, you just aren't sure if your pass implements it correctly.
For 2, this would imply insane things if applied to other fields. What is the correct period to amortize a bridge engineer's salary over? 50 years? 100? We still have some Roman bridges around, maybe we need to look in the thousands of years. Patents are good for 20 years, so any salaries that lead to a patent clearly need to be 20 year amortization. Copyright is life + 70 years, so graphical designer salaries should be amortized over at least 100 years.
I don't think there's any real logic here, it's just a way to balance the tax budget.
I don't think there's any real logic to it, it's just a way to balance the tax budget.
For 1, presuming that all software engineering is "research or experimental" is faulty. The vast majority of software engineers are implementing known things, and the "experimental" status reflects its reliability. Most "experimental" software isn't really doing experiments to answer questions, it's just checking whether an approach works correctly. I don't think anyone could honestly call writing an Okta integration for a SaaS app "experimental". You know that it will work ahead of time, you just aren't sure if your pass implements it correctly.
For 2, this would imply insane things if applied to other fields. What is the correct period to amortize a bridge engineer's salary over? 50 years? 100? We still have some Roman bridges around, maybe we need to look in the thousands of years. Patents are good for 20 years, so any salaries that lead to a patent clearly need to be 20 year amortization. Copyright is life + 70 years, so graphical designer salaries should be amortized over at least 100 years.
I don't think there's any real logic here, it's just a way to balance the tax budget.