Preferences

> Sam's PR announcement of all the tests that ChatGPT is passing

Can you link me to that?

> The world is filled with people/organizations who do the right thing almost all the time, but then use that clout to do a bad thing when it really matters.

That's a good point! but it's also an irrefutable charge. In fact, someone who behaved perfectly forever would be no less accusable of this. Btw I'm certainly not saying we behave perfectly—but we do take care to moderate HN less, not more, when YC-related interests are part of a story (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...). That's for reasons of self-interest as much as anything else. It wouldn't make sense to risk the global optimum for local gains.

> It sounds like all they need to do is ask one mod to take care of it, and it goes away pretty quickly.

People are going to feel like that's happening no matter what we do, but FWIW, we don't do that. We do downweight submissions as part of moderation practices that have been established for years, but a YC person doesn't have any more clout over that than you do, if you happen to email us and ask us to take a look at a particular thread (pro or con). And we always answer questions about what happened when people ask.

Btw if you feel like that randomwalker article is still relevant and can support a discussion of something specific and interesting—that is, not yet-another-generic-AI thread—go ahead and repost it and let me know, and I'll put it in the second-chance pool (https://news.ycombinator.com/pool, explained at https://www.hackerneue.com/item?id=26998308), so it will get a random placement on HN's front page at least for a while (how long depends on how the community reacts).


> Can you link me to that?

I can't, but really? Every major announcement from them has been top of page. And I don't disagree with that being the case. ChatGPT is THE story of 2023 tech, and their announcements are important to the tech industry. I just like all the discussions around this hugely important topic to be given the same freedom to succeed.

Thanks for the discussion.

dang OP
> Every major announcement from them has been top of page

As far as I know that's not accurate, or even close.

We're not playing favorites; all we care about is that the most interesting stories get the front page time, since there are many more submissions than space on the front page.

This item has no comments currently.